Media release
Joint inspection of adult services: Review of progress in Clackmannanshire and Stirling Health and Social Care Partnership
Last updated 30 October 2026
Critical gaps remain in the integration of services for adults living with mental illness in Clackmannanshire and Stirling, according to a new report.
An inspection in the Health and Social Care Partnership completed in November 2024 identified ten priority areas for improvement. The report released today highlights the extent to which progress has been achieved in relation to each of those areas.
The partnership was at various stages of addressing the ten identified areas for improvement. No areas showed significant improvement since the 2024 inspection, with progress limited to minimal or some. As a result, there was little or no evidence of positive impact on outcomes for people using services and their carers.
Inspectors noted the development of a number of high-level strategies and policies across the ten areas for improvement. These provided a good foundation for improving engagement with people, carers, and staff, and for supporting a more coherent approach to the planning and delivery of integrated services.
However, the gaps identified during the 2024 inspection remained evident at the frontline of services. The partnership’s ability to deliver integrated services effectively continued to be a significant challenge. A further factor was the complexity of the health and social care partnership arrangements of two council areas, with a shared integration joint board and single NHS board.
The lack of a fully functioning oversight structure limited the partnership's ability to monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of integrated services for people living with mental illness. As a result, it was unable to demonstrate the extent to which services were achieving intended outcomes or identify where improvement action was required.
Collectively, these factors adversely affected the partnership's ability to drive change and deliver improvement in a timely and effective manner. Overall progress was limited and had not resulted in sufficiently improved outcomes for people using services and their carers. Where positive outcomes were evident, these were often attributable to the commitment and collaborative efforts of individual staff rather than being supported by robust systems, processes, and governance arrangements.
Jackie Irvine, Chief Executive of the Care Inspectorate, said: “Overall progress was limited and has not resulted in sufficiently improved outcomes for people using services and their carers. Where positive outcomes were evident, these were often attributable to the commitment and collaborative efforts of individual staff rather than being supported by robust systems, processes, and governance arrangements.”
Robbie Pearson, Chief Executive of Healthcare Improvement Scotland, said "This report recognises the work undertaken by the partnership to strengthen its strategic foundations. However, progress has been slower than anticipated, and a number of the issues identified during our previous inspection remain. The partnership now needs to strengthen its oversight and governance arrangements to ensure meaningful improvements in outcomes for people using services and their carers.”
The full report can be read here.